But yeah idk what your budget looks like and I'm not really pricing these things out - just looking at it relatively. I'd rather take something I know is going to be supported for a while, in case I do want to upgrade again, then dropping money into a platform that's already dead. I just know the total cost of ownership of that is going to be cheaper but it may be more upfront.
So I'm asking this because of trying to figure out the best buy for myself, not to question your testimony or your friends' decision, but what did they do with newer AMD generations on the chipsets they had? Sure, it works, but did they feel anything missing? How did they fare referring to newer GPUs and PCIe generations (AM4 supports from PCIe 2 to 4, which is argueably a huge difference).
So buying AM5 might give you PCIe 5.0, but that's already showing limitations (in very special cases) with a 4090. Let alone a TI, and what AMD might come up with. As the main difference feature between generations, that came to my mind as a possible downside with updating your AM5 system without changing the mainboard. And keeping old RAM, since they also did improve over time etc.
So I'm asking this because of trying to figure out the best buy for myself, not to question your testimony or your friends' decision, but what did they do with newer AMD generations on the chipsets they had? Sure, it works, but did they feel anything missing? How did they fare referring to newer GPUs and PCIe generations (AM4 supports from PCIe 2 to 4, which is argueably a huge difference).
So buying AM5 might give you PCIe 5.0, but that's already showing limitations (in very special cases) with a 4090. Let alone a TI, and what AMD might come up with. As the main difference feature between generations, that came to my mind as a possible downside with updating your AM5 system without changing the mainboard. And keeping old RAM, since they also did improve over time etc.
I personally upgraded my board twice - I had a 1700X with a X370 board then eventually slotted in a 3900X to that board when that came out. Then eventually upgraded the board to a X570 with a 5900X but I didn't even need to go for a X570.. the only reason i did is because I wanted to free up the entire x370/3900X for a server. As far as features I never really cared for anything the boards were offering.. maybe nvme? I can't even remember if the 370 supported that or not. But it's not make or breaking my build.
As far as PCI-E, do you mean PCIe 4 is showing limitations?
I think PCI-E 5 is safe for a few generations.
At my resolution even a 4090 in 2.0 you're only losing like 6% performance on average if I stayed with that original board. On a 3080 (my current card) I don't even know if I'd lose any performance really outside of margin of error on the x370.
So in theory I could have kept my original X370 and RAM, went from a 1700X to a 3900X to a 5900X and a 1080Ti to a 3080 and maybe lose like 2-3% performance on the PCI-E limitation and like some file transfer performance from lack of nvme/pci-e 3 on my 980 pro.
I personally upgraded my board twice - I had a 1700X with a X370 board then eventually slotted in a 3900X to that board when that came out. Then eventually upgraded the board to a X570 with a 5900X but I didn't even need to go for a X570.. the only reason i did is because I wanted to free up the entire x370/3900X for a server. As far as features I never really cared for anything the boards were offering.. maybe nvme? I can't even remember if the 370 supported that or not. But it's not make or breaking my build.
As far as PCI-E, do you mean PCIe 4 is showing limitations?
I think PCI-E 5 is safe for a few generations.
At my resolution even a 4090 in 2.0 you're only losing like 6% performance on average if I stayed with that original board. On a 3080 (my current card) I don't even know if I'd lose any performance really outside of margin of error.
So in theory I could have kept my original X370 and RAM, went from a 1700X to a 3900X to a 5900X and a 1080Ti to a 3080 and maybe lose like 2-3% performancne on the PCI-E limitation and like some file transfer performance from lack of nvme/pci-e 3 on my 980 pro.
Thank you for your reply, this was exactly what I was wondering about.
If it was me upgrading and my system was that old I'd just wait and do DDR5. DDR5 isn't that much more expensive than DDR4 and at least you can carry it through multiple platforms. Like if you buy DDR5 + AM5 and a current 7000 series or wait for X3D 7K series you have a clear upgrade path for the next 3-4 years.. let's say 9000 series comes out 4 years from now and is sick good, you just drop it in. You won't get that buying DDR4 now or buying Intel now.
But yeah idk what your budget looks like and I'm not really pricing these things out - just looking at it relatively. I'd rather take something I know is going to be supported for a while, in case I do want to upgrade again, then dropping money into a platform that's already dead. I just know the total cost of ownership of that is going to be cheaper but it may be more upfront.
I am at that point I can choose like you said. I'm still waiting on 7x00X3D but I got my 4K OLED so my goals are different now. I WANT a 4K RTRT GPU BUT, AMD 7000 series is about to come out too...
So I'm just setting a point a of reference now:
5800X3D with bog 3200 RAM + FAST GPU or
12600KF/13600KF DDR4-4000 + FAST GPU
or eat RAMEN until 7x00X3D comes out with + FAST GPU.
Suprrised I am getting 40 -50 FPS at 4K native with no AA and Medium or HIGH settings with my old system. 😀
5800X3D, 13600 now for gaming or 7950X for MT( much better power efficiency).
If you have Ryzen 5000 or Intel 12 Gen, you can easily wait longer and just buy a GPU.
Still not beating the 5800X3D in many games especially beyond 1080p.
If 7800X3D is the same performance jump like last time then it'll take the gaming lead by about 10% i think.
Is this gaming power consumption
? Btw this is a useless test,all cpus are the same,clearly GPU limited.Go check computerbase.de, 13900k demolishes 7950x even with 88w power limit
I "upgraded" from a 5950x X570 to a 12900k....in truth it was a downgrade on everything but pure gaming fps and a few M.2 slots, because the plateform/chipset is really bad (single pcie slot useable, only stable with 2 dimms)
I could buy a 13900k my Z690 asus extreme is patched for it but I won't
I chose to spend almost 2k to go back to amd (keeping only the memory dimms) rather than buy a single CPU there are reasons why
As far as PCI-E, do you mean PCIe 4 is showing limitations?
I think PCI-E 5 is safe for a few generations.
not sure my comment will be useful but 99.99% of people still think that when motherboards say "if you connect and m.2 or pcie card your main x16 gen5 slot becomes 8x gen5" manufacturers clearly spam that gen5 everywhere to hide the truth
you don't get x8 5.0 bandwith aka x16 4.0...you get x8 4.0...x8 whatever gen your card is actually how it works
so as you graph does on those new 5.0 motherboards you get x8 4.0 aka x16 3.0 bandwith and lose 2% as soon as you are in the scenario where you main gpu slot goes x8
in worst more scary numbers it means your gpu bandwith goes from 25.6xGb/s to 13Gb/s on Z690 at least
you can test it yourself with 3dmark pcie bandwith test
closer than i expected, not a bad launch tbh, seems the e cores are paying off for now. though i will say it must hurt intel to be selling a large die for such a low price after all those years of selling fairly high margin desktop parts.
The difference is less but it's not no difference. Would need to see over a wider range of games.
I'm just saying people were writing off AMD here but in reality the 5800X3D competes with these price/performance on DDR4.
HU did a 12 games with 4090 and the difference between a 13900k and a 7700x is about 5%. A x3d will beat it almost certain.
I think PCI-E 5 is safe for a few generations. At my resolution even a 4090 in 2.0 you're only losing like 6% performance on average if I stayed with that original board. On a 3080 (my current card) I don't even know if I'd lose any performance really outside of margin of error on the x370. So in theory I could have kept my original X370 and RAM, went from a 1700X to a 3900X to a 5900X and a 1080Ti to a 3080 and maybe lose like 2-3% performance on the PCI-E limitation and like some file transfer performance from lack of nvme/pci-e 3 on my 980 pro.