NVIDIA Shield Android TV game console review

Mini and Desktop PCs 49 Page 1 of 1 Published by

Click here to post a comment for NVIDIA Shield Android TV game console review on our message forum
https://forums.guru3d.com/data/avatars/m/235/235224.jpg
GeForce Now is probably the more interesting part of it all, it runs surprisingly well and can see it taking off eventually. Thanks for the review Hilbert 😀 It's a powerful little device and definitely worth it.
https://forums.guru3d.com/data/avatars/m/254/254238.jpg
I have had one for 4 month now and I'm using it for media center and playing my pc games from my pc in the office to the living-room. I have it connected to a Marantz SR-7010 and a 3d Projector with 125" screen and I love it. It can play all my movie formats (.iso - .mkv - .avi etc. etc.) and most .iso formats it can also view the blu-ray menu. For now Kodi supports DTS-HD - DTS X - Dolby TrueHD - Dolby Atmos and of course all the other lower codec like standart DTS - Dolby digital. I have no issue with streaming games from my pc in 1080p60fps over LAN. Only thing I would like to change is that you have to manually go in and switch between 1080p 60Hz - 1080p 50Hz - 1080p 23.976Hz. So when you want to play you need 1080p 60Hz and for most movies 1080p 23.976Hz. I still miss the option to see 3D movies but it might come along.
https://forums.guru3d.com/data/avatars/m/246/246171.jpg
It seems very good for it's price, but I personally wouldn't want one. I'd rather pay extra for a gaming console or PC. Y'know what I don't get? This device is basically a Jetson TX1 with a nice enclosure, software, and accessories, but it costs a lot less. Sure, you might not be able to tweak it as much as the Jetson board, but if you wanted a small, powerful, and efficient PC, you could just buy one of these Shields and replace the OS on it. I've thrown around the idea of getting a Jetson TX1, but I'd much rather buy this Shield and gut it. Any chance of seeing the innards of this thing? 🙂
https://forums.guru3d.com/data/avatars/m/246/246171.jpg
I wondered why one corner is thicker. Yeah, 8W is at edge of passive cooling and poses no challenge for smallest of active. So it may be very quiet.
Honestly, I think if Nvidia made the housing out of some sort of metal, this could've been made with passive cooling. Keep in mind too - if 8W is the power consumption of the entire device, that would include the power draw of the fan itself, as well as other components unrelated to the processor. I can't imagine the CPU itself being more than 7W in this case. It's hard to know for sure though - the Tegra X1 is marketed as a 10W chip.
https://forums.guru3d.com/data/avatars/m/246/246171.jpg
That all depends on what you want to use it for. If you are strictly using it for a media streamer then yes I would get the FireTV.
If you want it strictly for a media streamer, there are cheaper options. I guess that depends on what your media expectations are, though. For example, if you watch a lot of 2K+ media and/or use surround sound, that'll lower your chances of finding a good cheap option. But if you're fine with 1080p and stereo, there are plenty of cheaper devices. Though these days, sometimes buying a smart TV is the best choice.
https://forums.guru3d.com/data/avatars/m/246/246171.jpg
I've got a smart tv...and the CPU is sheit. Standalone is still better and you can load Kodi.
Some TVs are complete crap. I personally have one based on Roku and it's actually pretty good. Every once in a while it fails to play some of my media, but it otherwise never stutters.
Looks great but it is unclear if you can stream your own games from your own PC to it or only games from the subscription service. Could someone confirm please?
It is based on Android, which supports platforms like VNC or Miracast. So yes, you should be able to stream from your PC.
https://forums.guru3d.com/data/avatars/m/259/259564.jpg
I think it's unfair to the device and to Nvidia to spend a significant portion of multiple pages talking about a failure on Kodi's part, most content in most apps do not exhibit any stutter. Nvidia gamestream will stream 4k/60, even over wifi, it is not maxed out at 720/1080p. Nvidia Grid is 7.99 USD a month. 9.99 Euros. Power consumption can be up to 20w if the CPU/GPU are pressed.
8W, small package, passive cooling. How does that thing feel to touch after prolonged use? If it gets hot, may we get IR photo? Price is quite good. I wonder if there are people using it for other than intended purposes. (And I do not mean Doorstop.)
It's not passively cooled, and it's not 8w. Here's a thermal shot. http://www.anandtech.com/show/9289/the-nvidia-shield-android-tv-review/9
https://forums.guru3d.com/data/avatars/m/246/246171.jpg
My problem with Smart TVs is the interface to stream your own content is crap. I have a huge movie library and the TV only lists these files in an alphabetical list that is such a pain to scroll through. I've seen some of the newer TVs actually have Android installed on them so theoretically you can install Kodi or other Android media apps but I don't know how the experience is. For me though, the Shield is by far the best box out there and being able to stream my PC games to my living room is an added bonus. I don't care for Nvidia's streaming service but I did try it during the free trial period when the Shield was released and it worked perfectly fine.
Roku has a few decent apps like Plex that would probably work well with your media collection. Though, I'm not sure if buying a separate Roku box is worth doing, compared to the alternatives. I'm not sure if Shield is the best option, but it's definitely a good value and more than good enough for most people. For some (like myself) it would be overkill and overpriced. There are a lot of cheaper and capable alternatives, like some of Hardkernel's ODROID product line. I'm personally using an ODROID-U2 as a home server, which does a lot of my media streaming. It does a bunch of other things too, like print server, torrent server, file share, automated backup system, FTP, and so on. I'd connect it to my TV, but the built-in Roku kinda obsoletes that need.
https://forums.guru3d.com/data/avatars/m/156/156133.jpg
Moderator
But the winner for best bang for buck must be the Fire TV. At $87 it's a steal.
I mean it's different, the specs and markets just aren't the same.
https://forums.guru3d.com/data/avatars/m/63/63215.jpg
I have a Roku 3 and regret getting it, it's games are rubbish, I should have bought an Nvidia.
https://forums.guru3d.com/data/avatars/m/199/199386.jpg
Not interested in this as an option to buy. TV/movie/media streaming can be done via a normal SMART TV, and if it is 2015/16 it shall have HDR, H265, WEB 2.0, Netflix ét all built into the TV. Games can be done via a games console for the same price including a controller. So, not worth buying from my perspective as there is nothing this has got that I do not already have - and, if someone was going to buy a 2160P/UHD TV this year, they would have no reason to buy this. I've have this discussion a lot regarding TV dongles and ways to 'boost' your existing TV so you may get Media Streaming content - go to the TV section of the forums and I'll see you there. On the topic of games running on a GPU in the cloud, I think nVidia are due to capture this market and own it - I really do not see anyone else with a viable solution for subscription based cloud GPU gaming, I just don't. The only problem they got is the games they have available are old (currently) or in low resolution. I'm watching this with keen interest. If Nvidia made televisions, I think they would be awesome...this device is not.
https://forums.guru3d.com/data/avatars/m/80/80129.jpg
But you need an Nvidia card? I think i'm buying this. It more future proof and versatile than Fire TV.
To use Nvidia's game streaming service you need an Nvidia card. There are remote desktop tools you can use as a way around this, but the experience isn't that great.
https://forums.guru3d.com/data/avatars/m/199/199386.jpg
@Loobyluggs : all TV aren't enough powerfull to play all codec (espcially H265) without problem. I tried latest TV Sony or Samsung , and some file H265 don't play at all. the same files work perfectly (with amazing picture) with Nvidia shield. Also kodi is not supported on 2015/2016 Tv , so u must have a player like Nvidia shield TV to have the benefits of kodi.
Which version did you try? The Linux/XBian version installed to your television via a USB stick appears to work very well...So, I still cannot think of a reason to spend any money on a STB anno 2016. If they want to produce a games console, like they had the chance to (kinda) with Sony/M$, or their own design, then fine. If they want to release a cheeeeeeapo STB/Stick/Remote for those that cannot afford a new television, then fine. If they want to work really hard on subscriber-based-cloud-GPU gaming, then fine - but with the caveat that they need current/new games. Slamming it all into one box, not fine as it has too many conflicts and overlaps with existing technology, and in particular the panel technology and RTOS's of established televisions. This box does not make the picture, the television does that.
https://forums.guru3d.com/data/avatars/m/80/80129.jpg
I have a Samsung 8500 48" TV and the SmartTV functionality of it sucks. Period. It's garbage. In fact I'd pay money for Samsung to strip all those features out because they constantly show banners on the top of my TV while I'm watching a movie about how some garbage service I don't care about is being discontinued. I hate SmartTVs. I've seen/used SmartTV's from Samsung/Sony/Panasonic/Sharp and LG. The interfaces, the speed, the application support, the input (controller) and even the voice recognition, it's all bad. I spent like 3 hours running wires through my wall to get my ShieldTV mounted/hidden and connected to my 8500 SmartTV because that's how much I hate it and feel that the Shield is better.
https://forums.guru3d.com/data/avatars/m/199/199386.jpg
I have a Samsung 8500 48" TV and the SmartTV functionality of it sucks. Period. It's garbage. In fact I'd pay money for Samsung to strip all those features out because they constantly show banners on the top of my TV while I'm watching a movie about how some garbage service I don't care about is being discontinued. I hate SmartTVs. I've seen/used SmartTV's from Samsung/Sony/Panasonic/Sharp and LG. The interfaces, the speed, the application support, the input (controller) and even the voice recognition, it's all bad. I spent like 3 hours running wires through my wall to get my ShieldTV mounted/hidden and connected to my 8500 SmartTV because that's how much I hate it and feel that the Shield is better.
Even the Panasonic 2015/16 running Firefox? Not used the Samsung ones, and haven't seen any reviews, but really that bad? Didn't it win awards?
https://forums.guru3d.com/data/avatars/m/259/259564.jpg
Not all games on the play store even support the controller so wont even install on this. If you really want a device to stream your games from your pc to your tv, then great, but remember latency. IMO just wasnt worth the price especially if you already have a new console or even a kindle fire stick. If you dont own either of those, its probably the best on the market fora play store game streaming device
Latency is completely a non-issue on a modern network. If I gave you two controllers and didn't tell you which was direct and which was streaming, you wouldn't know. You can also sideload apks without hacking or rooting it at all. Fire stick doesn't support 4k. Closest thing is the fire TV, which is only about 80 dollars cheaper